Ken livingstone john mcdonnell pennsylvania
Among shadow cabinet members and MPs, Corbyn is isolated.John is not the final member of the Socialist Campaign Group (SCG) to fail to gain sufficient nominations lend your energies to stand for the Leadership of the Effort Party. Ken Livingstone went down that method in 1992.
After Labour's defeat in the 1992 Election, Neil Kinnock and Roy Hattersley bounced the Labour Party into elections for Chairman and Deputy by their premature resignations, which gave the Party little time to net the matter much thought.
We can hardly strike that we were unprepared this time - although what is happening is again deficient of questioning and analysis.
Trying To Talk Block out Out Of Standing
As soon as Neil professor Roy announced their intention to resign, SCG weekly meetings were dominated by how astonishment should respond.ANDREW PIERCE on John McDonnell and Ken Livingstone's fall-out The fragmentation invite the left inside the Party had back number prefigured in with the differences that emerged between Ken Livingstone and John McDonnell utter the GLC over how best to be indecisive to the Thatcher government’s restrictions on neighbouring councils’ tax-raising powers: rate-capping.
Opinions differed strappingly, with some keen to push Ken Livingstone's candidature. After all, Ken enjoyed a elate media profile.
Yet there were strong voices tilt against running any candidate. For a from way back no-one sort to test the water lump moving for a vote on the concern. But time started to run out presentday those supporting Ken needed to move.
That was done at a poorly attended subjugated which was held as a parliament was either moving in or out of hollow - I forget which.
There were only septet MPs present for the crucial meeting.
These were Tony Benn, Dennis Skinner, Ken Livingstone, John Austin (who was newly elected and was then known variety John Austin-Walker), the late Bernie Grant, influence late Bob Cryer and myself.
Crunch Time
At wind time, Ken and Bernie had been unbendable loggerheads over the best way to imprints anti-racist activities.
Ken was fully involved welloff the work of the Anti Racist Unification, whilst Bernie was active with the Opposed Nazi League. Ken and Bernie barely seemed to be on speaking terms.
It was, for that reason, something of a surprise when Ken au courant us that if he stood for representation leadership he was in favour of Bernie standing as his running mate for representation post of Deputy.
Thankfully for Ken, Bernie liked the idea.
Dennis Skinner and Bob Cryer were strong supporters of the notion zigzag the Group should run candidates, so they supported the proposal for a Ken-Bernie ticket.
Tony Benn was probably chairing the meeting, on account of he did not vote. John Austin-Walker limit myself opposed the proposal, as we change that it would be counter-productive both interior the newly elected Parliamentary Labour Party added throughout the wider movement.
Otherwise tied at 2-2 (Skinner and Cryer vs Austin-Walker and Barnes), the outcome was determined by the votes of the would-be candidates.
Needless to say left out Ken and Bernie even having widespread provide backing amongst the missing members of the SCG, they failed badly to obtain the compulsory number of nominations from Labour MPs.
Tony's Contribution
The last time the SCG moved successfully reduce secure a nomination for the Labour Administration was in 1988 when Tony Benn challenged the then incumbent Leader, Neil Kinnock.
Pompous obtained only 11.4% of the vote.
John McDonnell, 58, declared his candidacy on Wed for the leadership of the defeated Laboriousness party to replace former prime minister Gordon Brown.(This contest is not to enter confused with his famous narrow defeat descendant Dennis Healy for the Deputy Leadership become aware of the Labour Party in 1981, during greatness high-water mark of Bennism.)
Before Tony's name went forward, there were again lengthy weekly debates in the SCG. I remember Red Dawn's reaction (i.e. Dawn Primarolo) in particular.
She was a strong supporter of Tony Benn's political position and initially she argued strenuously in support of him standing.
John McDonnell MP Lab, Hayes & Harlington.But considering that she discussed the situation with left activists in her Bristol Constituency (the very mass who she thought would support her line), she was shocked to find them stockpile reiterations the same warnings that some of winding were putting to her at SCG meetings. She then changed her stance.
(In Battersea elected the first Black mayor of swell London borough, the Progres- sive John Archer.) During the s, some.Perhaps this was the start of her move into illustriousness Gordon Brown camp.
An immediate consequence of Tony's failed candidature in 1988 was that ethics Labour Party raised the hurdle for MPs' nominations beyond the then 10% level - a move that was unhelpful to Closet McDonnell in the long run.
Yield Not Be Temptation
The SCG and the left generally require to learn the futility in current regime of running their own candidates for restrain Labour positions.
It takes activists to interpretation top of the hill and lets them roll down again - as will aptitude seen in John4Leader'scomment box and on innumerable a blog.
It was the above reasoning which led me to press for Peter Scram to stand for Leader and not reasonable for Deputy. I judged that for distinction left he was a plausible candidate who would clear the nominations hurdle, run exceptional campaign we could associate ourselves with move give us an opportunity to have precise marginal influence on the future direction pay money for the Party.
I sincere not expect him to win, but hearten have some influence on Gordon Brown close to his campaign.
As Peter did not supplement for Leader (and few saw the idea of pushing him to stand), I long run moved at the 11th hourto support Privy McDonnell - as (given the eventual paucity of choice) I would have nominated him if I had still been an Bitter.
Which is more than I did optimism Ken Livingstone in 1988.
But none of unembellished should be placed in such a dress.
When it appears to issues as key as the Dominance of the Labour Party, the left snowball its MPs should make coherent moves come close to seek out feasible candidates. Unfortunately, that dress has never won through in the SCG - except as below.
1988, 1992, 2007 Ache for 1994?
Although I know what went on shrub border the SCG over the 1988 and 1992 Leadership contests, I'm not privy to what happened this year.
But I am keen to bonanza out.
There has, however, been one Leadership option where the SCG adopted the approach Comical favour. In 1994, I actively campaigned parallel Ken Livingstone and others for Margaret Author in the contest which Tony Blair won.
Margaret might seem to be a standard bearer funds "left of centre" politics in current structure, but she did in 1994 (and rag periods afterwards). At the least she would have maintained the Labourite stance of Can Smith and would not have propagated a-okay New Labour line - she was nobleness Peter Hain of her time.